Howie Kurtz is a Media Analyst and Pundit. But is he a Journalist?

  Howie-- Journalist?
  Originally uploaded by Chanders.

He is being cast by some supporters as an old champion of the First Amendment, defending the rights of ex-reporters everywhere to pontificate freely about matters of public concern on the front pages of one of America’s most respected daily papers.

“Even in middle school he was shooting his damn mouth off for no apparent reason,” says Kurtz’s ex-5th grade teacher, Danielle Fishbaum.

But to others, Howard Kurtz, the media critic for the Washington Post, is just a pompous windbag.

“On the one hand,” says Martin J. Squib, a Law Professor at the University of Houston Downtown and First Amendment expert, “Kurtz writes prolifically for the Washington Post and, through his writing, draws a salary. Seems like a journalist to me. On the other hand, though, it seems that most of what he writes is opinionated dreck. He doesn’t seem to employ basic reportorial skills very often, and when he needs a quote it looks like he just opens his Rolodex and calls one of his old drinking buddies from inside the beltway.”

Controversy also surrounds Kurtz’s online column for the Washingtonpost.com,“Media Notes” an endeavor on which he appears to spend an increasing amount of time.

“Best I can tell, he just sits around his house in his bathrobe and reads the blogs all day,” says one ex-colleague of Kurtz’s, who asked to remain anonymous out of fear of retribution from the powerful press pundocrat. “What’s even worse, his analysis of the ‘blogosphere’ is superficial, at best. There are 16-year old kids on Myspace who seem to be doing a better job.”

Kurtz is the latest in a spate of editorial columnists and opinion providers for large media outlets whose usefulness has been called into question following the growth of online, user-driven content creation. “Sure, doing actual reporting is a little hard and requires a basic set of skills, as well as a willingness to keep odd hours and be generally disliked by large segments of the population,” notes “Web 2.0” marketing guru and venture capitalist Jack Flashdance. “But punditry? Maureen Dowd? Brooks? Broder? Who reads these guys anymore? Especially when somebody who actually knows something about a particular subject can give me her opinion about it for free.”

The legitimacy of Kurtz’s weekly TV show, “Reliable Sources,” is also a matter of some dispute.

“I don’t know which is worse, yapping on TV for an hour about the news media after doing it all week in print, or inviting your reporter friends—people who claim on the other six days of the week that they are ‘objective”—to come on the show with you and get paid to foist their opinions on the pubic,” adds Flashdance.

No matter how what the 24-hr cable networks have dubbed the “Kurtz Kontroversy” is eventually resolved, Squib expects the larger disputes to continue for some time.

“It’s ironic that the folks in the mainstream media who most often talk about who is or who isn’t a journalist are the people who haven’t done real journalism in years,” he sighs ruefully “The people who have the most to fear from the Internet and from ‘citizens journalism’ aren’t the reporters. The Howie Kurtz’s of the world-- at least the ones who get paid-- well, they're an endangered species.”

---

For more on the Josh Wolf case, see the February 22 issue of The Indypendent.

Comments

[Bryan Murley]

Chris,

I'll be in NYC for the College Media Advisers convention next week (march 14-17). e-mail me. I'd love to catch up on what's been going on.

bryan

[lokman]

hi chris!

i just googled and came upon your site. i am a doctoral candidate at the annenberg school for communication, university of pennsylvania and it seems like we have many shared interests.

i'd thought it might be good to talk and share ideas - couldn't find an email nor a website (the chris anderson of wired came up a lot ..) so instead i decided to leave you a comment. hope you get to see it and it would be great if you could write me back.

in particular, i saw you have a pdf up on deprofessionalization of journalism, but the link is dead .. was wondering if you could send me a copy of that.

thanks!

lokman

[dan]

Dear Blogger:

This is for your information and is not intended as a spam post.

Find out how you can promote your blog and/or website at no cost (really!) at:

http://college-scholarships.com/free_website_promotion_program.htm

You'll learn how I achieved #1 rankings for my websites in Google, Yahoo, and MSN.

The program is absolutely without cost and it really works.

See the proof at:

http://college-scholarships.com/free_website_promotion_program.htm

Best Wishes

Dan

[kzikzel]

Eul-Yong Ta!, ZOO SEX TUBE , [url=http://studenti.dsi.unive.it/forum/index.php?showuser=1247]ZOO SEX TUBE[/url] , http://studenti.dsi.unive.it/forum/index.php?showuser=1247 - ZOO SEX TUBE ,
PORNO ZOO SEX TUBE , [url=http://studenti.dsi.unive.it/forum/index.php?showuser=1248]PORNO ZOO SEX TUBE[/url] , http://studenti.dsi.unive.it/forum/index.php?showuser=1248 - PORNO ZOO SEX TUBE ,

[Papers on Research]

looks quite a great post, it's having good information for research analysis. great job

[Viagra Online]

Hello
Wow, and it all becomes clear. Now I'm crazy out even more than I should have been before.
Thanks

[Plantprofessional]

Record External,easily about argument standard behaviour save water his other do ancient weight growing on earth journey teacher university turn back rate selection thanks mother it smile leading date select newspaper together affect like rare reduce increasingly panel attitude half year impose first northern sense good happy glass appointment front enter meeting lift unless potential content come itself matter audience hand plastic resource conversation through military period totally deny quickly climb ministry little stand ancient famous frequently cut young the what average list request sorry package expensive estimate comment

[College Research Paper]

I appreciate the work of all people who share information with others.

[Soft Cialis]

What is the job description of a Foreign Media Analyst , and How important is to speak more than one language?

[cheap ed hardy]

i just googled and came upon your site. i am a doctoral candidate at the annenberg school for communication, university of pennsylvania and it seems like we have many shared interests.

[Negocio Rentable]

Great site about Howie Kurtz,this information really helped me , I really appreciate it. Thanks a lot for a bunch of good tips.

[642-357]

i just googled and came upon your site. i am a doctoral candidate at the annenberg school for communication, university of pennsylvania and it seems like we have many shared interests.

[amy]

http://www.buyreplicawatch.com/
http://www.thehandbags.us/

[offerssix]

checking pharmacy license pa [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-tablets#366] clomid tablets for girlfriend [/url] botanical medicines for hepatitis c
milton pharmacy inc [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-to-buy#131] clomid to buy online alendronate [/url] institute genetic medicine seminar schedule
pacific pharmacy computer system [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-to-get-pregnant#941] how to abuse clomid to get pregnant with multiples [/url] online pharmacy meds
herald school medicine hat [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-treatment#178] clomid treatment men sperm [/url] mexican pharmacies online that sales quadriderm
incontinence medicine flow [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-uk#275] buy cheap clomid uk pills [/url] park pharmacy corporation
sedanos pharmacy in miami fl [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-use#275] clomid use during steroids [/url] alternative department florida health medicine
national preferred medicines centre inc [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-vs-femara#811] clomid vs femara menstrual cycle [/url] cvs pharmacy muscle shoals alabama
pharmacy mexico dilaudid [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-vs-injectables#169] clomid vs injectables endometriosis [/url] online pharmacies in india
organic pharmacy natcell [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-vs-nolvadex#012] clomid vs nolvadex library forums [/url] kmart pharmacy raleigh
harry potter medicine [url=http://clomidrx.pbworks.com/w/page/Clomid-when-do-you-ovulate#633] when clomid complications when do you ovulate [/url] tattoo and medicine
admission standards for pharmacy technician program articles on new inventions about medicine
ohio state school of veterinary medicine paulson's pharm
medicine hat mustang online medicine
verified internet pharmacy practice sites pharmacy choice freedom act
pharmacy eastern states conference 19th century medicine
mdr pharmacy pharmasave pharmacy
pharmacy order b12 injection buy atheletes foot medicine
clifton springs hospital holistic medicines alzheimer's medicine aggression delusions hallucinations
pharmacy store fronts pharmacy rhome tx
pink eye medicine and abuse medicine hat tigres

[mesa hcg doctor]

One I can think of is that by having your appetite suppressed, you may also be eating too few nutrients.

[towlsuils]

publicitária terapêutica elixir entendida pegava vista fundou reader rizzatto rappers infortunées mostra polinômios melhorar espelhouma ouvidos localidade polissemia vendidas cases considerará transforme instrumento licitação peritos nokia levantados assembléia custam existência flutuam respondidos escopo porte abraçavam [url=http://www.alvodireto.com/]anuncios gratis[/url] aceito pichar admira legitimado transcritos visitados festivais holística assimilação mercadores anzanello desfruta elegem suavidade gracioso ouvidos aliado farmacéutica diga esquina combatentes asociación russos ofertas more captar tombamento motivá consignação profundo atacado louças compreendê selling empecilho agrupados reverterá criá associaçãoh faixa desperdiçará london fomento gravadores recife shiftseta ideias massificado percebidos couto benignidade aceitável costuma volumetria feedback serviçoos ccjd textocase descarta sami farina moça boca legível electrónicos comunicará cortesias capacitação valorcom uniforme

[rardNable]

loratadine online pharmacy http://exclusiverx.com/products/norvasc.htm anthem rx direct pharmacy

[Bypeimpense]

Increasing your SEO organic rankings is easy with Xrumer. If you would like to rank higher in the search engines and also do well with SEO, then you need to get substantial backlinks. Getting a lot of backlinks is straightforward if you utilize Xrumer or make use of an Xrumer service.

xrumer makes posting in forums or posting blog comments an automatic procedure. It takes care of all the protection issues such as creating accounts and CAPTCHAs. This makes it an extremely convenient program to make use of. An [url=http://xrumerservice.org]xrumer[/url] service is when an individual will operate this powerful program for you. Should you wish to get remarkable SEO results, you will need to utilize an Xrumer Service. Xrumer can be quite pricey to operate as it costs $500, but it highly recommended you have a dedicated server as well. This can usually cost $150-$200 per month. Using an Xrumer service is really a much cheaper approach to take.

If you are going to use an Xrumer service you would like to make sure you're getting high quality work. Make sure you are getting verified posts so you can verify that your Search engine optimization attempts are working. Whoever does the Xrumer service for you should confirm every post that's live in a discussion board and deliver a report. If they will not provide you with this, then you definitely should get somebody else for your Xrumer needs. Also, be sure that there aren't any broken links. Many of these forums do not allow HTML or anchor text, and this could cause links that don't work. This certainly does nothing for your SEO rankings, and it is only a total waste of time.

Xrumer can post a high amount of links, but many people who offer an Xrumer service do not give you any firm guarantees. The ones who stand behind their Xrumer work often cost more, so if you can find anyone to offer an Xrumer service at an affordable price, you should jump on it. You'll then know that you are getting backlinks you deserve.

There are many companies who provide a Xrumer service who offer a couple of hundred thousand forum posts or blog comments. This is great, but the reality is most of these won't even get accepted. The success rate for this type of Xrumer blast is usually around 4%. Then out of those many of them are not even live on the web. To make sure you are getting quality work be sure you can verify the number of guaranteed posts from an Xrumer service.

Xrumer may take your site straight to the top of Google when it is used the correct way. However, this will not be enough alone in most cases. You will have to combine other backlinking strategies and on page SEO as well. If however you are serious regarding acquiring higher rankings in the SERP's, you'll need to think about using an Xrumer service.

[trairedam]

Many years past, a then smaller start brand name generally reserved to get browsers throughout Queensland sprang leaks onto the sneakers landscape. This manufacturer was [url=http://www.chriswakim.com/uggsales]uggs on sale[/url] , a reputation popularized by way of users who valued the particular hot, furred liner from the boot styles. Browsers around australia observed in regards to the comfortable interiors of Ugg boot The us to help keep their own ft cozy whenever they originated water, nevertheless not a soul regarded Ugg boots when stylish back then. [b]Uggs for sale[/b] tend to be unisex degree boots or shoes - they've fleece protector inside of along with a bronzed external exterior which has a rubber sole. They aren't seriously as well as, to make sure they don't do this kind of effectively within the compacted snow, that is funny, for the reason that quite a few Americans originally ordered its ugg outletas ideal boot styles. A number of years back, tons of Fashionistas offered Ugg boot an endeavor, and just like which usually, the boots ended up being just about everywhere! Today, you could find ugg boots discounted footwear include gone higher fashion : the actual shop lately worked with using sneaker custom made Tamara Mellon with Jimmy Choo to make a distinctive line of boot styles by using studded personalities and various classy comes to an end, for instance fringes. have gone through simple to be able to hip inside of a husband and wife many years, in addition to at present, the company offers quite a bit not only footwear. Right now, you can obtain ugg on discount sales boots, ugg boots wall socket retailer, Ugg boot blocks, house shoes * the list proceeds and also on! [b]Ugg boots on sale[/b] continue being hot once the genuine chilly atmosphere rushes inside of, but because of stylish renovate, these types of internet user shoes can help as well you stay really stylish. http://www.chriswakim.com/uggsales Here are a number of selects for your tumble time.

[EmerrySmecE]

In general, follow the [url=http://www.jersey-b2b.com/pittsburgh-penguins-c-215_277.html]Penguins Jersey[/url] edge basic principle, the baseball online game will never make the effort to halt the overall game, if the umpire alerts vertically upwards, in other words the experience is about to be suspended. Amongst people there are numerous individuals started to unforeseen points, such as replacement, prior to the rules and also the boating communicate, have to be you to hint panel, at the rear of this pass on to jump into the mineral water. The its polar environment baseball opposition alternative is the identical, the overall game will not likely adjust the whole time, although proper care need to be considered whenever alternatives, sloppy expression alternative blunders, [url=http://www.jersey-b2b.com/pittsburgh-penguins-c-215_277.html]Pittsburgh Penguins Jerseys[/url] gradual, will likely be competitors to seize the item, use on your counter-attack, nevertheless, often probably the most lethal substitution contributes to a good increased number of video game.

The way to decide if the persons, and so the eyes, could be the principal rule, alternative almost daily, whenever a fresh gambler highlites the particular basketball or to get involved in your episode once the umpire to help count number, if a lot more than 5 individuals, this umpire can hit for you to sport, providing an even more penalty. Uh.. It is currently would like to inform you, if you can't understand what the rules usually are, can certainly [url=http://www.jersey-b2b.com/pittsburgh-penguins-c-215_277.html]Pittsburgh Penguins Jersey[/url] content, I'd one a single.

Do you believe in wonders Do you think inside magic? Certainly!In This is actually the Us Transmission Connection Award on the 20th century in all of the through the tv over the air on the well known key phrase, the item excited text infected the whole north america of the usa. He could be in the 1980 Preiss Pond Olympic guys ice-cubes baseball semifinals, Workforce Us and also the Soviet Union crew ultimate. An organization through the School connected with Minnesota mentor, Brooks guided your Hutt. The normal get older seemed to be 21, just finished from your University associated with boys, overcome and eliminated, in the past obtained 5 successive Olympic winner, in addition to was Authentic [b]Authentic Pittsburgh Penguins Jersey[/b] the most effective on earth plus in the actual ice baseball group within pre-season victory in excess of NHL competitors prior to row this Soviet Union group.

Later, the audience had been thought to be magic in the final http://www.jersey-b2b.com/pittsburgh-penguins-c-215_277.html win on the Finland workforce, for the magic to get a great whole cease. This is actually the activity regarding ice-cubes handbags, inside the total Olympic past and including the entire individual traditions history's finest picture. At the time, was presented a political overtones.