The Future of Local News Revisted: Josh Breitbart on the Pending Sale of the Inky and DN

Josh Breitbart has a thought provoking and informative post over at Civil Defense documenting the latest moves in the about-to-be-pending-sale of the Philadelphia Inquirer and Daily News. This is something I've followed with some interest ever since my attendance at the Philly NORGs conference in March. There's a lot to digest here, so I thought I would largely leave aside the actual details of the sale (except when relevant to other points) and talk a little bit about some of the ways that I think concerned independent media activists should thinking about the economic, financial, and political changes shaking the news industry.

First, lets look at the big picture. As Josh notes, he's someone who has "worked to de-professionalize journalism for his entire adult life." The increasing (and increasingly nuanced) attention that long time independent media activists are paying to developments in the mainstream, corporate media world is only surpassed by the increased attention that corporate media powers-that-be are paying to independent media. I talked a lot more about this in the aftermath of the NORG's meeting, so for now all I'll add is that there would have been a day when just about anyone who cared about alt. media would have barely mustered a shrug of the shoulders with regard to the pending Knight-Ridder sale. Indeed, there's still plenty along these lines to go around, as  Rolando de aguiar writes on the Philly IMC site, in reaction to Josh's post:

"I am very disappointed to see an Indymedia feature offering such a facile treatment of this situation. These two abysmal papers--faces of the same overvalued coin--have for many years been hostile to progressive issues ... the idea that Philadelphia's African American community would be "simply shut out of the world of information" is absurd and offensive; rather than crying about the quality of the potential suitors for these two rags, independent media should see this crisis as an opportunity.

By and large, I agree with the thrust of Josh's post, but I think Rolando also makes some good points. A couple of specific reactions first, before I get to the punch-line, so to speak. First, with regard to the professionalization of journalism. Josh writes, regarding the Newspaper Guild:

"The Newspaper Guild came into existence at a time when journalism was in ill repute. In the 1930s, the Guild brought a new professionalism to journalism and established a sense of respect for newspapers in the eyes of the general public. They set as their mission "constant honesty in news, editorials, advertising, and business practices; [and to] raise the standards of journalism and ethics of the industry." They won pay raises for reporters who were getting paid less than unionized drivers and printers, giving birth to journalism as the professional occupation we know today.

Readers know that the professionalization of journalism is a particular interest of mine, and I wanted to point out (yet again) the ambiguity of the professionalization project with regard to journalism. There's no better way to do it than to quote James Carey, who has argued that the professionalization of the reporter, along with fostering a growth of objectivity, also helped to create journalists as a separate class increasingly distanced from, and standing in for, the public at large. In other words, while the growth of objectivity and professionalization may have raised the quality of information received by citizens, it undermined both their trust in journalism and the very fabric of public life that made public deliberation possible in the first place.  I think this is a fundamental insight of the independent media activists, even if they don't often frame their arguments this way. This isn't to say that professional journalism is bad, just that its a double-edged sword. Can one witness the truth emerge via a deprofessionalized conversation? What about the quality of information? There aren't easy answers to these questions, but they're worth asking, at least.

My second and broader thought has to do with Josh's recommendations. This is related to Rolando's point that media activists should see the Inky's sale as an opportunity, not a disaster. Josh points readers in several direction if they hope to comment on the pending McClatchy sale: they can submit comments via 2papertown.com. There's no reason not to make this kind of noise, but I think its a bit late. Not just with regard to the McClatchy sale, but by and large, with the entire state of the American newspaper industry. Are we just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic here?  Michael Shapiro has an amazing story in the March/April CJR about the rise and fall of the Inquirer which can stand in for a much larger collapse of the newspaper business under the weight of its own conservatism (in both senses of the word) and greed. In other words, does it really matter much who buys the Inquirer and Daily News? There's no easy way to answer the question, "is journalism possible under capitalism?" but an easier question to ask is, "is journalism possible under the current stage of corporate, investor driven, globalized capitalism?" Jeff Jarvis says yes, and thinks all the talk about evil corporate journalism is bullshit. I say that I'm not so sure.

I'll take off my ill-fitting Marxist hat for now; it doesn't really fit me very well, anyway. But I'll just say this: we are in a moment of opportunity, no matter who buys the decaying remains of the Knight-Ridder empire. This isn't to say that we can't try to make the best out of a bad situation, and that the folks in Philly don't deserve the best, most progressive, most racially forward-looking news they can get. But I don't know if they they'll get it from Brian Tierney, or Yucaipa, or Mort Zuckerman, for that matter. Something new is being born in the journalism world that we can see the vague outlines of but can't quite recognize, exactly. Its not exactly the world that either old-style journalists or their alt. media antagonists expect, I don't think. But its coming.

Comments

[tovorinok]

Hi

Great book. I just want to say what a fantastic thing you are doing! Good luck!


G'night

[govokinolij]

Hello

Looks good! Very useful, good stuff. Good resources here. Thanks much!

Bye

[yyberto]

Very interesting site![@999.txt||10||r||4||

[Hersones]

DI4YFo Hi Rabzebuddy! Google.

[Hersones]

DI4YFo Hi Rabzebuddy! Google.

[go]

http://google.com google

[Alex]

XC4XBO test, dating in lebanon pa, poyazm, hide porn trail, =-((, tightblackpussy, hqxv, classic car touch up paint, %[[, some people tell me i need help ...kottonmouth kings lyrics, faaxh, 8 year old girl models, wbswm,

[cheap ed hardy]

Looks good! Very useful, good stuff. Good resources here. Thanks much!

[generic viagra]

coins are very interesting objects, as a child and my mother gave me coins, was an exaggerated happiness I felt, and since young I always interested in collecting them, these items are great

[cialis online]

I just moved to the US and I'm having trouble finding international and national news merged into one show. I just want the traditional news where the anchor reads the introduction, he/she talks about it, a video is shown and she just moves onto the next story.

I dont' want a discussion show, just traditional news :) Thank you. Please tell me what channel the show is on and what time as well as the timezone you're referring to. Thank you

[propecia online]

Gottschalk, 55, is only the fifth publisher in the 109-year history of
the World-Herald. That averages out to better than 20 years a
publisher. "I have the luxury of thinking not in terms of months or
quarters or years, but of generations," he says...

[Volker from Germany]

Hi,
I randomly came on this side and would like to leave nice greetings. I would be glad if you visit my homepage also! Maybe you want to visit Sylt Westerland in Germany http://www.MeerblickSylt.de or the Baltic Sea http://www.OstseeblickHolm.de for vacation?! We have there very nice flats with a nice view. Maybe we'll see soon!
Kind regards

[lacoste shirts]

A great man is always willing to be little—R. W. Emerson
It is not enough to be industrious, so are the ants. What are you industrious for?— H. D. Thoreau

[ed hardy swimwear]

I like your article. Will always support you!

[amy]

http://www.buyreplicawatch.com/
http://www.thehandbags.us/

[Apcalis]

I have flair in writing and wish to grow ahead in the same field. Can you help me out in knowing how do you manage to be so good and perfect in your writing? I want to know if there is any coaching class or exams that I may have to join to polish my English language.

[buy generic viagra]

Outstanding, what an amazing way to convey your current thoughts and opinions? Cool I must say? I do think you're correct. Hope to read more write-ups from your end and I am seriously looking ahead for it.

[Personalized football jerseys]

knowing how do you manage to be so good and perfect in your writing? I want to know if there is any coaching class or exams that I may have to join to polish my English language.

[snowlin]

http://ikmolpy.multiply.com/

[cialis online]

Please one more post about that.I wonder how you got so good. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog is so perfect

[cialis price]

Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. Keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. This was actually what I was looking for, and I am glad to came here! Thanks for sharing the such information with us.

[Life Insurance Quotes]

nybjfjoezqfoefou, Life Insurance Quotes, LkTDcdm, [url=http://lifeinsurance-blog.net/]Life Insurance[/url], tiVhUhW, http://lifeinsurance-blog.net/ Life Insurance Quotes, KflBCVd.

[Denver corporate housing]

urbjljoezqfoefou, Compare cialis levitra viagra, GxXNXhP, [url=http://sacumparviagra.ucoz.ro/]Viagra flomax[/url], BlxfiDZ, http://sacumparviagra.ucoz.ro/ Viagra, xPnfJWR, Solar Panels, fqlywiH, [url=http://smallsolarpanelsblog.com/]Small Solar Panels[/url], QNeomCt, http://smallsolarpanelsblog.com/ Small Solar Panels, rLxsyYC, 'african mango', PmXYLjc, [url=http://africanmangodietpill.org/]African mango supplements[/url], nMojisQ, http://africanmangodietpill.org/ African Mango, SbYmtUZ, Bath and Body Works Coupons, bhibJYa, [url=http://www.bathandbodyworkscoupons.us/]Bath and Body Works Coupons[/url], uGKUbxc, http://www.bathandbodyworkscoupons.us/ Bath and Body Works Coupons, sNYFFXX, Avg free anti virus, DferWED, [url=http://www.avg-free.us/]Avg Free[/url], ZZnXoWW, http://www.avg-free.us/ Avg 2011 free, LRRCjQw, Denver Corporate Housing, GLSbHfC, [url=http://denvercorporatehousing.net/]Denver corporate housing[/url], RnusbSU, http://denvercorporatehousing.net/ Denver Corporate Housing, CnxkIwc.

[Denver corporate housing]

urbjljoezqfoefou, Compare cialis levitra viagra, GxXNXhP, [url=http://sacumparviagra.ucoz.ro/]Viagra flomax[/url], BlxfiDZ, http://sacumparviagra.ucoz.ro/ Viagra, xPnfJWR, Solar Panels, fqlywiH, [url=http://smallsolarpanelsblog.com/]Small Solar Panels[/url], QNeomCt, http://smallsolarpanelsblog.com/ Small Solar Panels, rLxsyYC, 'african mango', PmXYLjc, [url=http://africanmangodietpill.org/]African mango supplements[/url], nMojisQ, http://africanmangodietpill.org/ African Mango, SbYmtUZ, Bath and Body Works Coupons, bhibJYa, [url=http://www.bathandbodyworkscoupons.us/]Bath and Body Works Coupons[/url], uGKUbxc, http://www.bathandbodyworkscoupons.us/ Bath and Body Works Coupons, sNYFFXX, Avg free anti virus, DferWED, [url=http://www.avg-free.us/]Avg Free[/url], ZZnXoWW, http://www.avg-free.us/ Avg 2011 free, LRRCjQw, Denver Corporate Housing, GLSbHfC, [url=http://denvercorporatehousing.net/]Denver corporate housing[/url], RnusbSU, http://denvercorporatehousing.net/ Denver Corporate Housing, CnxkIwc.

[Compact lcd game tetris]

ptmqrjoezqfoefou, Teeth Whitening, sXJxrBX, [url=http://www.teethwhitening.ws/]Teeth whitening clairemont[/url], oWqedkr, http://www.teethwhitening.ws/ Teeth Whitening, uhmcefP, online poker, XzJghCk, [url=http://onlinepokersi.com/]Play poker online free[/url], hNigtIi, http://onlinepokersi.com/ online poker, zxeaSOs, NFL Betting, CnnKfPk, [url=http://marcellecreativecrochet.com/]NFL Betting[/url], hkNiCqX, http://marcellecreativecrochet.com/ NFL Betting, LXHmHnu, tetris game, hcNmbuz, [url=http://tetrisawesome.com/]free tetris[/url], bocWDhY, http://tetrisawesome.com/ Juego del tetris, BEKiZKJ, cheap reseller web hosting, tABglNX, [url=http://webhostingreview.org/category/reseller-hosting/]unlimited reseller hosting[/url], OCIsmRH, http://webhostingreview.org/category/reseller-hosting/ reseller hosting, HgrXJFY, Safe emule servers, bfLWEyp, [url=http://free-emule.com/]emule[/url], lXIQhak, http://free-emule.com/ Emule morphxt connection settings, rNKavfh.